• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Feud of the Year (2013)[16] – The Authority (vs. Daniel Bryan)
  • Feud of the Year (2014) – Seth Rollins (vs. Dean Ambrose)
  • Most Hated Wrestler of the Year (2013)[17] – The Authority
  • Most Hated Wrestler of the Year (2014)[18] – Triple H and Stephanie McMahon
  • Most Hated Wrestler of the Year (2015) – Seth Rollins
  • Wrestler of the Year (2015) – Seth Rollins
  • Tag Team of the Year (2013)[19] – The Shield (Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns)
  • PWI ranked Seth Rollins 1 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2015.[20]
• WWE
  • World Heavyweight Championship (1 time) – Randy Orton
  • WWE Tag Team Championship (2 times) – The Shield (Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns), The New Age Outlaws (Road Dogg and Billy Gunn)
  • WWE United States Championship (2 times) – Dean Ambrose (1), Seth Rollins (1)
  • WWE World Heavyweight Championship1 (4 times) – Randy Orton (2), Seth Rollins (1), Triple H (1)
  • André the Giant Memorial Trophy (2015) – Big Show
  • Money in the Bank (2014) – Seth Rollins
  • Royal Rumble (2016) – Triple H
  • Slammy Awards (8 times)
    • Breakout Star of the Year (2013) – The Shield (Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns)
    • Faction of the Year (2013) – The Shield
    • Insult of the Year (2013) – Stephanie McMahon for insulting Big Show
    • Match of the Year (2014) – Team Cena vs. Team Authority at Survivor Series
    • Rivalry of the Year (2014) vs. Daniel Bryan
    • Superstar of the Year (2015) – Seth Rollins
    • Trending Now Hashtag of the Year (2013) – The Shield for #BelieveInTheShield
    • "What a Maneuver" of the Year (2013) – Roman Reigns for the spear
  • Vincent J. McMahon Legacy of Excellence Award (2016) – Stephanie McMahon
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Best Booker (2015) – Triple H (with Ryan Ward)[21]
  • Most Improved (2013) – Roman Reigns[22]
  • Most Overrated (2013) – Randy Orton[22]
  • Most Overrated (2014) – Kane[23]
  • Tag Team of the Year (2013) – The Shield (Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns)[22]
  • Worst Feud of the Year (2013) – vs. Big Show[22]

1 ^ Orton's first reign was when the title was still known as the WWE Championship.